
Personal injury claims are frequently based on evidence that can help to prove how the accident occurred, who might be liable for the accident, and what impact it had on the injured person. Photographs, medical records, police reports and witness statements are still all vital pieces of evidence, but digital evidence is another source that is valuable. Records can be created from everyday online activities which assist in understanding events prior to, during and after an accident.
A personal injury lawyer Pittsburgh will take digital footprints into account when looking at the circumstances of an injury claim. Social media posts, location history, electronic communications and online transactions can provide further information to support or refute statements made by the parties involved.
How Social Media Activity Can Provide Supporting Evidence
Social media sites enable individuals to post photos, videos, comments and personal posts. These types of posts are typically established for communication or entertainment functions, but they can be helpful if someone is involved in an accident and files a legal claim.
For instance a photo taken just prior to an incident could be a scene of a house, a hazard or an activity that was associated with the incident. A video that a bystander takes during a crash or after a crash could show a portion of the crash or after the crash. Comments even about an accident can lead to witness identification and/or to finding additional evidence.
Social media posts can also bring about problems, though. Insurers can check a claimant’s social media for details of physical impairments or recovery. For example, if someone is injured and attends an event, a picture of them at the event doesn’t necessarily mean they have recovered from their injury. It may have been short and/or restricted or it may have been carried out before the discomfort became overwhelming.
Digital content needs to be taken into account, for this reason. An accident or injury doesn’t always need a lot of information to be established in a single post.
Using Location Data and Digital Timestamps to Establish Timelines
A person’s location and activities can be automatically captured by smartphones, and other connected devices. This data can contain GPS history, time data, navigation data, and data from location based applications, depending on the settings of the device and the services offered.
The records can aid the investigators in creating a time frame prior to an accident. For instance, location history can offer some clues to the possible location of an individual just before a reported crash. Photographs and/or videos with dates may also be useful in determining when an event took place and whether the accounts that are available are consistent.
However, there are some drawbacks to using location data. The GPS location may not be accurate, and the time on the GPS device could be subject to change due to settings or technical problems. The investigators should also determine if it is the injured party’s or another person’s information.
Preserving Digital Evidence and Addressing Privacy Concerns
Digital evidence may perish or become unavailable or alter over time. Information on social media platforms can be deleted, surveillance data can be overwritten and apps can automatically delete older information. It may therefore be crucial to keep important documents at an early stage if someone is investigating a personal injury claim.
There are a number of practices that can be considered to safeguard potentially useful digital evidence:
Keep original file: Whenever possible, photographs, video, messages and documents should be kept as they are.
Make notes of pertinent dates and information: It is important to keep track of when and where a file was created, to assist in establishing a connection between the file and the incident.
Don’t edit or alter content: Modifications to digital files could lead to questions about their authenticity.
Identify potential sources: It may be on smartphones, computers, accounts on the cloud, security systems or communication systems.
Another key factor to consider is privacy. A personal injury claim does not automatically get access to all of the digital records. Some information may be confidential and collected and/or shared only in accordance with the legal requirements. Attorneys can review pertinent records and the proper methods for their retrieval.
Frequently Asked Questions
Is evidence of location history able to determine the location of an accident?
Location history can be useful to create a timeline, or to show the latest locations of devices at the time of an incident. It should be compared with other evidence as GPS information does not always give a precise location.
Does digital evidence need to be destroyed following an accident?
No. Any messages, photographs, videos or other documents that might be relevant should be kept. The removal or editing of information that is related to a claim may cause problems when investigating the claim.
May an insurance company investigate the activity of a claimant on the Internet?
Insurers can access information on the internet which is public and available to the general public in determining a claim. Any decisions made based on social media should consider the context and constraints of the social media material.
Conclusion
Digital footprints can be of great value in a personal injury case. Social media, location data, electronic communications and timestamped documents can be useful to provide context on timelines, witnesses, hazards previously reported, and to resolve discrepancies.
Digital information does not supplant medical records, evidence and/or the testimony of witnesses, but can complement an investigation if properly preserved and analyzed. Combined with the traditional types of documentation, these records will help legal professionals to gain a better understanding of an accident and the circumstances of an injury claim.
